Policy checking checklist: issued policy vs. the quote
The issued policy just landed. What the CSR or account manager checks against the accepted quote, line by line: named insured, limits, deductibles, forms, AI and waiver endorsements, premium. With a discrepancy log and a correction email.

Example request, Tuesday morning: "The policy for the landscaping account finally came in. Can you check it before I send it to the client?" The CSR now has three documents open: the quote the client accepted, the binder, and a 60-page policy behind the dec page. Open the quote. Open the dec page. Read the forms schedule line by line. Look for each requested endorsement in the list, then in the policy itself. Compare the additional insured schedule with the client's contract. Note every difference, email the underwriter, wait, then do it again on the revised policy.
This checklist is for CSRs and account managers in US commercial lines agencies. It starts once the policy is issued. Quote comparison comes before: it is the step where the client picks an offer. Policy checking asks a narrower question: does the policy the carrier issued say what the client accepted?
Gather the file before you open the policy
Put the following side by side, each with its date and version:
- the final quote the client accepted, including any revised version;
- the client's written instructions and the bind request;
- the binder or the carrier's bind confirmation;
- the application and supplementals sent with the submission;
- the expiring policy, for a renewal;
- the contracts that require specific endorsements (lease, construction contract, vendor agreement).
The quote you compare against must be the last one, not the first draft. If the forms schedule lists a form that is not in the package, ask for it and keep the check open. The ACORD preparation checklist covers the application side: which answers were confirmed by the client and which were still open at submission.
The Big I's June 13, 2025 article on preventing the most frequent agency E&O claims recommends reviewing new and renewal policies and documenting client communications. The checklist below is one way to organize that review.
The policy checking checklist
The left column is what you check, the middle column is where it sits in the issued policy, and the right column shows the kind of mismatch to look for. Examples, for illustration.
| What to check | Where it sits in the issued policy | Compare against | Example of a mismatch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Named insured and entities | Dec page, named insured endorsement | Accepted quote, ACORD 125 | The LLC on the quote, only the DBA on the policy; a second entity missing |
| Policy period and locations | Dec page, location schedule | Quote, building schedule | Two locations quoted, one on the schedule |
| Limits, sublimits, aggregates | Dec page, coverage part declarations | Quote, client instructions | Per project aggregate requested, per policy aggregate issued |
| Deductibles and retentions | Dec page, wind and hail or named storm endorsement | Quote | A percentage wind and hail deductible where the quote showed a flat amount |
| Forms and endorsements | Forms schedule | Form list on the quote, contract requirements | An endorsement listed on the quote, absent from the forms schedule; a different edition date |
| Additional insured, primary and noncontributory, waiver of subrogation | Endorsements and their schedules | Client contracts, past COI requests | Blanket wording requested, a scheduled endorsement issued with one name |
| Business auto | Auto dec, covered auto symbols, vehicle and driver schedules | Quote, vehicle list | Symbol 7 (specifically described autos) where the quote showed symbol 1 (any auto); a truck missing |
| Claims-made terms | Dec page, retroactive date endorsement | Expiring policy, quote | Retroactive date reset to the new inception date |
| Premium, taxes, fees, audit | Premium page, audit condition, invoice | Final quote | A fee or surplus lines tax that was not on the quote; payroll basis different from the submission |
Two habits save time. Check the forms schedule against the actual forms, not only against the quote: a form can be listed and missing, or present and unlisted. And read the endorsement, not its title: two endorsements with similar names can carry different conditions.
For lines your agency rarely writes, send unfamiliar wording to the person in the agency who knows that line. A general checklist does not replace their review.
Log each discrepancy, not a second summary
The useful output is not a rewritten summary of the policy. It is a short log of what does not match, with enough detail for someone else to pick up the item tomorrow.
| Field | Example |
|---|---|
| Policy and version | GL, issued version received on the 12th |
| Item | Location schedule |
| Expected, with source | 2 locations, accepted quote p. 2 |
| Issued, with source | 1 location, policy location schedule |
| Request sent | Correction requested from the underwriter |
| Owner | Account manager on the account |
| Next follow-up | Date agreed with the carrier or the wholesaler |
| Status | Open, awaiting clarification, correction requested, closed after check |
| Proof of closing | Endorsement number or revised policy, checked |

An item closes when the revised policy or the endorsement has been received and checked, not when the underwriter replies "will fix". If the carrier says the difference is intentional, the account manager decides what the client needs to hear, and the agency's copy of the policy is never edited by hand to match the quote.
A correction email to adapt
Subject: Issued policy review, [named insured], policy [number]
Hi [underwriter],
We reviewed the issued [policy or endorsement, version] against the quote accepted on [date]. The quote shows [expected item, page]. The issued [dec page, schedule or form number] shows [issued item]. Can you confirm whether this is an issuance error and send the corrected [endorsement or policy]?
Is anything needed from the insured in the meantime?
Thanks, [name, agency]
Describe the difference exactly, with page and form references. Avoid calling everything an error before the carrier answers, and don't promise the client a backdated fix. Keep the email and the reply in the account in the AMS.
Close the loop on the corrected policy
When the corrected documents arrive, check the item you raised and anything that changed with it: a reissued policy can move other values. Keep the earlier version in the file so the next person understands the sequence. Then the account manager decides whether the client receives the revised documents with a short explanation.
Two numbers tell you more than "policies checked per day": the number of open items and how old they are. Also watch the files you could not check because a form was missing, and items reopened after a correction.
Quote comparison and policy checking stay two separate steps. For the earlier one, see our guide to comparing insurance quotes with AI. For where policy checking fits in the renewal calendar, see the commercial renewal checklist.
Where AI fits in policy checking
AI is good at the reading part: pulling limits, deductibles and form numbers out of a long policy and lining them up with the quote. Each value still has to point to its page so the reviewer can confirm it. A value the tool did not find stays blank: it does not mean the coverage is absent. The CSR or account manager decides what counts as a discrepancy and what goes to the carrier.
Policy checking with Covera
Covera's Day-to-day assistant, one of its agentic AI workflows for CSRs and account managers, checks issued policies against the quote: limits, endorsements and named insureds. It works from your AMS, your emails and the policy documents, and shows the source of each finding, so your reviewer opens the page in question instead of rereading the whole policy.
Your team decides what counts as a discrepancy, what goes to the carrier and what the client hears. The same assistant drafts COIs with the right certificate holder, answers coverage and billing questions from the policy, and chases missing documents and signatures by email, each ready for your review before it is sent.
Example request in the chat: "COI for the bakery on Main St, new landlord as holder." The assistant prepares it from the policy on file and you review it before it goes out. For commercial property, Covera groups buildings by address and adds public property data, which helps check the location schedule on the issued policy.
The quotes it checks against come from the Quote & compare workflow, which lines them up side by side on premium, deductible and coverage before binding. To try it on your own accounts, start the 2-week free trial.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between policy checking and comparing quotes?
Quote comparison happens before the client chooses: it lines up competing offers. Policy checking happens after binding: it compares the policy the carrier actually issued with the quote the client accepted, the binder and the client's instructions.
Is checking the dec page enough?
No. The dec page shows limits, deductibles and the policy period, but the forms schedule and the endorsements decide how coverage works. An additional insured endorsement, a waiver of subrogation or a new exclusion only shows up there.
What should a CSR do when the issued policy doesn't match the quote?
Log the difference with both sources (quote page, policy page or form number), email the underwriter or the wholesaler with the precise item, and keep the item open until the revised policy or an endorsement arrives and has been checked.
Does policy checking protect the agency from E&O claims?
No checklist guarantees that. A documented check shows what the agency compared, what it asked the carrier and how each item was closed. The Big I lists policy review among its tips to prevent common E&O claims.
How do we test a policy checking tool before using it on live accounts?
Take a file where you already know the discrepancies, run it through the tool and compare the findings with your own log. Check that each finding points to the page or form it came from, and that missing endorsements are flagged, not skipped.


