How to compare insurance quotes with AI
Three homeowners quotes, two ways of writing the wind and hail deductible: 7 rules for account managers who compare carrier quotes in ChatGPT or Claude, and two free tools that apply them.

Example request from a homeowner, after three quotes went out: "They all look the same to me. Which one should I take?" Before the account manager can answer, the three carrier PDFs have to be lined up. One states the wind and hail deductible as 1% of Coverage A, another as a flat $2,500. One includes water backup, another leaves it out without saying so. One quotes extended replacement cost on the dwelling, the others do not mention it.
Retyping all of it into a spreadsheet takes time. Handing it to ChatGPT or Claude with no method risks an invented coverage in a document your client will read. AI does this job well when you give it rules. Here are the ones we use at Covera, and two free tools that apply them for you.
What AI does well, and what it gets wrong without instructions
An assistant like ChatGPT or Claude reads PDF quotes, scans and phone photos. It lines up coverages worded differently by each carrier and writes a summary a client can read. That is most of the job, and it is fast at it.
Without instructions, it also makes the same four mistakes:
- it fills a gap with what a homeowners policy "usually includes";
- it compares a 1% wind and hail deductible to a flat $2,500 one as if they were the same;
- it computes rough savings between premiums;
- it picks a "best option", which is not its call.
The seven rules below fix these four mistakes.
The 7 rules
1. Give it every document, and only for the same risk
You need 2 or 3 quotes for the same insured and the same property or business. Policy forms, endorsements and applications complete a quote: they fill its rows, they never count as one more offer. If a page is unreadable, the AI must say so, not write "Not stated in quote" in its place.
2. Impose a coverage grid per line of business
A grid sets the sections and rows, line by line:
- homeowners: Coverages A to F, extended replacement cost, water backup, ordinance or law, all-peril and wind and hail deductibles;
- business owners policy: building, business personal property, business income, general liability limits, deductibles, exclusions;
- group health: deductibles, out-of-pocket maximum, copays, network, prescription tiers.
Without a grid, every comparison comes out in a different shape, and rows go missing without anyone noticing.
3. Zero invention: "Not stated in quote"
A coverage the quote excludes and a coverage the quote does not mention are two different things. Your instructions must say it plainly: every value comes from a quote, written as it appears there. Nothing on a row: "Not stated in quote". This is the rule that protects your E&O the most.
4. Same row, same thing
Replacement cost against actual cash value, a percentage deductible against a flat one, per occurrence against aggregate: these values do not convert. Keep them as written and mark the row "not comparable". The client sees the gap, and you explain it.
| Row | Carrier A | Carrier B | Carrier C | In the comparison |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wind and hail deductible | 1% of Coverage A | $2,500 | $2,500 | Not comparable (percentage against flat) |
| Water backup | $10,000 | Excluded | Not stated in quote | Written as each quote states it |
| Dwelling valuation | Extended replacement cost, 125% | Replacement cost | Replacement cost | Written as each quote states it |
Fictional carriers and values, to show the format.
5. No math, no verdict
At the top of the table: the premium, annual or monthly, as each quote states it. No total, no savings, no score, no "recommended option". The choice and the advice stay with the producer or account manager.
6. Two versions: one for you, one for the client
Your own checks stay in the conversation: expired quote, missing document, values that contradict each other. The client PDF only holds facts and 2 to 5 numbered points to note, in plain words, each with its source (carrier, page).
7. Review the draft before sending
A draft first, then the final version. Check three things: the values match the quotes, "Not stated in quote" appears where a quote is silent, and the gaps that matter carry their numbered reference.

Two free tools that apply this method
Nobody retypes these rules into a prompt for every account. So we put them into a free quote comparison tool, with the coverage grids and the PDF layout. It comes in two versions.
In Claude: one command to paste
In Claude.ai, with code execution turned on: attach your quotes (PDFs, scans or photos), paste the Covera command, send. Claude first shows the table and what to check; you reply OK, and the final PDF arrives.

Get the quote comparison tool for Claude, free, by email.
In ChatGPT: a skill to import once
In ChatGPT, import the Covera skill once (Plugins, Skills, Import). Then, in any chat, attach your quotes and ask for the comparison.

Download the skill for ChatGPT, free.
Both versions produce the same PDF: coverages side by side, numbered points to note, "Not stated in quote" where a quote is silent. The footer states that the carrier's quote and policy form prevail.
One caution: a quote holds your client's personal information. Use a Claude or ChatGPT account that fits your agency's data policy.
A comparison is only as good as the reading behind it. To know where each answer sits in a policy (dec page, forms, exclusions, endorsements), see how to read an insurance policy and summarize it.
Beyond one account: quote and compare in 4 minutes
The free tool handles one account at a time, from quotes you already gathered. The work before it remains: rekeying each carrier portal, then attaching every quote to the client's account in your AMS. Our tips to quote faster on carrier portals cover that step by hand.
In Covera, quoting and comparing are one workflow, Quote & compare:
- 2 minutes to quote: one click fills every carrier portal you pick, even with partial data, and gives a first estimate while the prospect is still on the phone. You check each screen and submit. See how Quote & compare handles carrier quoting.
- 2 minutes to compare: the quotes come back side by side on premium, deductible and coverage, with gaps flagged, on your agency's letterhead. See how it handles quote comparison.
The comparison also flags the exclusions specific to each quote, the clauses one carrier excludes and the others do not, and exports to Excel when you want to rework the grid. At Hello Risk, a commercial broker, a comparison takes 3 minutes (median) against 30 by hand, and 14 of 16 comparisons became the client advice letter. Read the Hello Risk case study.
The rules of this article still apply: every value comes from a quote, nothing is invented, and the recommendation stays with your team. Before it, Intake & data collection turns the client's email into a submission in 1 minute. After it, Bind & sync updates your AMS when the client signs.
To run it on your own accounts, try Covera free for 2 weeks.
Frequently asked questions
Can I compare insurance quotes with ChatGPT or Claude?
Yes, as long as you give them rules: a coverage grid per line of business, no invented values, no math and no verdict. Covera's free quote comparison tool, for Claude or ChatGPT, applies these rules and produces a PDF you can send to your client.
Can AI get an insurance quote comparison wrong?
Yes: without instructions it fills gaps with what a policy usually includes, or compares a percentage deductible with a flat one. Hence three safeguards: "Not stated in quote" when a quote is silent, "not comparable" when two values differ in kind, and a review of the draft before the final PDF.
Can AI compare quotes from several carriers on the same risk?
Yes, if every quote is for the same account and line, and you give it the coverage grid for that line. Each carrier gets a column and each limit, deductible and endorsement a row, written as the quote states it. A coverage one quote does not mention shows "Not stated in quote". The producer reads the grid and makes the recommendation.
How do I compare a 1% wind and hail deductible with a flat deductible?
You do not convert one into the other in the comparison. Write each deductible as the quote states it, mark the row "not comparable", and explain to the client what 1% of Coverage A means in dollars on their own home.
Is an AI quote comparison advice to the client?
No. It is a summary of the quotes provided: the carrier's quote and policy form prevail, and it is not a binder of coverage. The recommendation stays with the producer or account manager.
What is the difference between the free tool and Covera?
The free tool handles one account at a time, from quotes you already gathered. Covera's Quote & compare workflow also fills the carrier portals, then lines up the quotes on every account, connected to the agency management system, on the agency's letterhead. 2 minutes to quote, 2 minutes to compare.


